Letter: We All Deserve More Than Performative Politics

We all  deserve more than performative politics

This situation isn’t unique to the beautiful beach town of Marshfield. Across the country, we’re seeing a wave of performative politics infiltrate local government — and it’s taking a toll on the communities that deserve better.

Take, for instance, Marshfield’s new Select Board Chair, Eric Kelley, who has voiced opposition to the board’s tradition of passing proclamations. These include proclamations to recognize Marshfield as a Purple Heart Community, support for LGBTQ+ residents, suicide prevention efforts, initiatives to address opioid and substance use, and most recently, ADA upgrades to make playgrounds accessible for individuals with disabilities. While some may not see their importance, local town proclamations play a vital role in recognizing community achievements, raising awareness about important issues, and fostering a sense of unity and pride among residents. 

There’s a growing phenomenon in local politics — the “anti-candidate.” The one who claims to stand for change by opposing everything. But what exactly is the change they’re proposing? When pressed for specifics, the answer is often vague: “We want transparency. We want things to be different.” Yet change without a plan is not leadership. It’s disruption for the sake of optics.

We hear the phrase “We the People” often — but let’s not forget that it includes everyone. Veterans. Individuals with disabilities. People struggling with addiction. Members of the LGBTQ+ community. True community leadership means standing up for all of us, not just the loudest voices or those who fit a particular mold or the people who supported you.

A town can’t move forward on defiance and division. It thrives on collaboration, empathy, and an open mind. Yes, we elect leaders to represent us — but we also need voters to show up. Because when they don’t, critical decisions are made by a vocal few, and others are left to bear the consequences.

We won’t stay silent, and we won’t let policies that harm our neighbors go unchallenged. Marshfield is better than this — and so is our country. We must demand better from those who claim to serve us, because leadership should be rooted in integrity, inclusion, and a genuine commitment to the well-being of all.

Janice Maloof Tomaso